[
Cross-posted from
Gay Atheists on
Atheist Nexus.]
As a feminist, I think about gender a lot, but not always for the
reasons people assume. While I recognize that females have legitimate
physical sex differences from males that we must never trivialize, I
also cringe when I see how society loves to perpetuate the gender
binary. So, what is gender? Here is an excerpt from a very good essay
(click link to read the rest):
COMPONENTS OF GENDER
A core component of Queer Theory is that gender is performative, but if
this was necessarily so, it would invalidate transsexualism from the
outset. Since the treatment of gender identity disorder recognizes that
the brain cannot be sufficiently changed and that the body must be
altered so it aligns with the mind, it seems that at the very least
identity is a factor of gender outside the sphere of performance.
Androgynes are a sort of transgender people with the gender identity of
both a man and a woman or neither. For them, the notion that sex is
between the legs while gender is between the ears is key. Because they
are neither men nor women, these non-binary gender variants are most
expediently differentiated as male-born and female-born. The remaining
categories are intersex, M2F (male-to-female transsexual), and F2M
(female-to-male transsexual). For more on androgynes,
http://androgyne.0catch.com is recommended.
From my own perspective as an androgyne, gender's makeup is comprised
of gender identity, gender presentation, gender performance, and gender
role. Gender identity concerns how you think, gender presentation how
you look, gender performance how you act, and gender role how you
contribute socially. Any of these aspects of gender can be mutually
exclusive of another depending on the individual and/or circumstance.
Gender presentation is like the flipside of Bornstein's gender
attribution, since it hinges on how you yourself -- rather than others
-- interpret your gender cues.
While gender role tends to go with gender identity, it doesn't always.
For example, there are male nurses and librarians and female security
guards and construction workers who arguably have a traditional gender
identity. It is also entirely possible to have a gender identity and
gender role that does not match up with one's gender presentation and
gender performance. Just because someone feels a certain way and
performs certain tasks doesn't mean they have to look or act the part.
Copyright 2006 Stephe Feldman
Survey!
1. What is your gender identity - how you
think?
2. What is your gender presentation - how you
look?
3. What is your gender performance - how you
act?
4. What is your gender role - how you
contribute socially?
My answers:
1. Gender Identity - My thoughts feel genderless. From early childhood I used to contemplate how I didn't feel "right" as a girl, but then I knew I wouldn't feel "right" as a boy either ("cuz I hate sports" was my innocent rationale, haha). I saw no gender in others that represented myself, so I did my best to follow whatever path made me happiest. Though there are both straights and gays who identify genderqueer, I feel that my lack of internal gender is a strong contributor to my queersexual orientation. (Yes, I just made that word up. Isn't that special?)
2. Gender Presentation - I look female. I am physically female and have no problem dressing female, since that is an aesthetic that I enjoy, though I wouldn't say I feel compelled to look female. Honestly, I don't feel very compelled to look any particular way at all. I tried wearing makeup in middle school, but I found it boring and useless. I've become even more lazy these days: I shop for mostly black clothes to simplify my options, and most mornings I don't even remember to brush my hair!
3. What is your gender performance - how you act?
Um... well, I really couldn't say. I think that my performance encompasses many masculine traits as well as feminine ones, though probably heavier on the feminine side. IDK, I'd have to ask someone who isn't inside my head. Anyone want to tell me how gendered I act?
4. What is your gender role - how you contribute socially?
This answer is the opposite of #1 (genderless); here I am both genders in full measure. I was in the military, and now I'm doing clerical work while I study business and raise a child. I am all things to all people. ;)